Home Top News On Matters of Race, Randall Kennedy Demands Thinking Over Feeling

On Matters of Race, Randall Kennedy Demands Thinking Over Feeling

Kennedy is someone who studiously resists feeling over thinking, and in considerable part for that reason “Say It Loud!” is not a book most will be inclined to take on vacation. For example, the history and aftermath of Brown v. Board of Education are seminal matters to any true understanding of America’s racial history — as Kennedy notes, 10 years after the decision in 1954, only a touch more than 1 percent of Black kids in the South were going to school with whites. However, various essays in this book together provide this case with a detail that few beyond historians and legal scholars are likely up for.

Overall, despite the title of the book, Kennedy, unlike James Brown, is not one for saying things “loud.” The one time in the book he even starts to do so is when he surmises how he would feel if he encountered a monument to the unvarnished bigot Woodrow Wilson: “I would smilingly give him the finger and shout with satisfaction, ‘Look at me and my people now!’” But even here there is a certain starchiness in the phraseology — (“smilingly” giving the finger and shouting “with satisfaction”) that brings us back to a deeply temperate writer.

Only in his unhesitantly acid take on Clarence Thomas does Kennedy even hint at a bit of what some call thunder. Kennedy once wrote a deft critique of the foundations of critical race theory and, predictably, took some heat for it. To be familiar with his oeuvre is to miss that piece here. Technically it appeared too long ago to qualify for the roughly 20-year span of these essays (though one of them is based on a piece that appeared earlier). I can’t help wondering if Kennedy omitted the essay out of a worry that in today’s climate of controversy over “C.R.T.,” certain right-wing elements might find it useful. If this, along with a judgment on that piece Kennedy recounts from the Harvard Law professor Derrick Bell, is what led Kennedy to refrain from anthologizing that essay, then the decision qualifies as (1) considered but (2) by no means “loud.”

Finally, while “Say It Loud!” may not always be exciting reading, Kennedy is the kind of writer who gives you the sense that in the end he’s always just plain right. Race in 2021 differs from race in 1961 solely in matters of politeness? A “new Jim Crow”? Such ideas can seem electric and, combined with the sense they lend of being on the side of justice, they can be as irresistible as they are fantastical. Kennedy does not pretend otherwise: “To adequately address the crises we confront now requires more than habitual incantations of Brown” or allusions to “segregation” and “the new Jim Crow.” But then, claims that Black people just need to shape up and “get real” have little more purchase upon concrete or moral reality. We will not gain anything by returning to a punitive, unreflective Gilded Age version of social justice. Kennedy’s take, one gleans, is that progress has indeed happened — “we are,” he says, “beneficiaries of antiracist struggles” — but that getting further will require change not just in Black behavior but also in society itself, through “future movements for enhanced racial equity.”

But then we must recall that Kennedy has also said he doesn’t expect a “racial promised land” in his lifetime. He assumes progress will be gradual and, one senses, relatively undramatic. And in this, as in almost everything about his views on race in America, Kennedy is both resolutely temperate and probably right.

Source link

RELATED ARTICLES

Opinion | Education Doesn’t Inoculate Us from Vaccine Hesitancy

About a year ago, Jessica was quoted in an interview as saying that while other advanced nations had social safety nets, the United States...

California Woman Charged With Arson in Starting Fawn Fire

A woman from Palo Alto, Calif., was charged with arson in connection with a wildfire that has burned about 9,850 acres and damaged more...

Sloppy or trolling? Canadian spy agency welcomes release of ‘not spies’ from China in exchange for Huawei exec’s freedom — RT World News

Two Canadian citizens, who were accused by China of going after its military secrets before being...

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Benelli Scooter Model Seta 125

Seta 125 scooter; High quality products from the Italian brand Benelli Do you spend a lot of time in big city traffic? How...

Opinion | Education Doesn’t Inoculate Us from Vaccine Hesitancy

About a year ago, Jessica was quoted in an interview as saying that while other advanced nations had social safety nets, the United States...

“Startup Gin” again put Serbia on the world map: Investors are happy to invest in Novi Sad and Belgrade

This is stated in this year's report "Startup Genome", which was presented in London yesterday. When it comes to investing in the innovation and startup...

2.8 million people are employed and 352,000 are out of work

Namely, the number of unemployed persons in that quarter was 232,700, while the number of employed persons in the second quarter of last year...